Week 3 Winners and Losers

Carmen’s shirtless mess:

EEK. Disaster. It’s too bad, because with an actual shirt and if the pants fit better, it would be good. But hey, construction counts! (See also: Sweet Pea and Ricky–also with failures in construction.)

Jack’s winning design:

Jack’s definitely wasn’t my favorite, although it was certainly one of the best. My favorite? Actually, none of the top three. I’d say either Chris March’s, Jillian’s, or Rami’s, although my taste in what men in real life wear is much more conservative than anything you’d see on Project Runway. I’m not really into men dressing all flashy.

Chris March–again a surprise, considering he’s a rather flamboyant costume designer!

Jillian Lewis. She’s really under the radar, and she’s not gonna win. She’s good, but she’s not outstanding, not knock-em-dead–at least not yet. But as far as menswear goes, I don’t want to see something that’s particularly arresting.

Definitely the most conservative look–Rami’s, which surprised me. I frankly didn’t know what to expect from him, considering his usual style. If I had to buy any of these for a man, I’d buy this one. I guess it’s too “boring” for Project Runway and Tiki Barber, though.

To see and rate all of the designs, go here. Which were your favorites? Which was your least favorite? And what were Tiki and the judges thinking by giving Christian’s hideous design a pass?!

–Beth